Our Fault (2025) Movie Review – Where to Watch Online
Our Fault (original title Culpa Nuestra) marks the emotional conclusion to the Culpables trilogy, bringing together conflicted hearts, past betrayals, and the question: can love truly overcome resentment?
While the first two films laid the groundwork for Nick and Noah’s tumultuous romance, this third installment attempts to tie all loose ends — for better or worse.
In this review, I’ll examine the plot, direction, performances, strengths and weaknesses, and then dive into where to watch Our Fault (2025) in the U.S. plus predictions and streaming strategy. Let’s jump in.
Synopsis / Plot: Reunion at a Wedding, Resentments Resurface
At Jenna and Lion’s wedding, Nick and Noah unexpectedly cross paths again — years after their breakup. Their emotional chemistry remains alive, but old hurts stand between them.
Nick, heir to his grandfather’s business empire, has built walls around his heart. Noah, finally stepping into her own professional journey, is wary of being hurt again. As their reunion unfolds in the lush backdrop of wedding ceremonies, tension builds.
Complications arise in classic melodrama fashion: misunderstandings, a love triangle, secret-keeping, and emotional confrontations. Nick struggles with forgiveness; Noah wrestles with pride and lingering pain. Will their renewed connection survive these tests — or will resentment prove too great?
Director Domingo González co-wrote this finale with Sofía Cuenca and Mercedes Ron (the author of the original novels).
This film is officially positioned as the third and final chapter of the Culpables saga.
Direction, Screenwriting & Tone
Domingo González casts a glossy aesthetic over the film — wedding dresses, sweeping scenery, romantic lighting — all wrapped in high-stakes interpersonal drama. Thematically, the movie tries to balance mature love with emotional melodrama.
However, pacing is uneven. Some critics note that Our Fault jumps time rapidly or relies on montage to skip over gaps in logic — for instance, how characters “magically” move between locations or reconcile contradictory statements. Some viewers found the transitions jarring and the plot thread connections tenuous.
“the time jumps??? she’s getting a flight to ??? … where was she before that and why should Simon lie …”
“rote scenes with music and landscapes fill time, only for a chaotic final 20 minutes of nearly everything happening at once.”
These objections reflect a sense that narrative clarity was sacrificed for emotional spectacle.
That said, the film leans heavily into romantic tropes — broken promises, dramatic reveals, love triangles — so if you’re invested in the characters, it can deliver emotionally satisfying moments.
Performances: Chemistry, Conflict, and Emotional Stakes
Nicole Wallace returns as Noah, a character torn between guarding her heart and embracing vulnerability. She channels a quiet strength and emotional turmoil, especially in scenes where forgiveness is demanded rather than earned.
Gabriel Guevara as Nick brings brooding intensity. His struggle to forgive, regulate emotions, and show humility is central. Their on-screen chemistry remains the engine of the film, and it’s what keeps the central conflict compelling, even when the script slips.
Fran Morcillo as Simon (a secondary love interest) receives mixed reactions: some viewers found his presence perfunctory, the character lacking depth or clear motivation, a narrative placeholder rather than a fully fleshed-out foil.
Supporting cast members make efforts to add dimension, but many subplots (family reconciliation, side characters’ arcs) are underdeveloped. The film chooses to focus on Nick and Noah’s emotional arc, sometimes at the expense of narrative cohesion.
Strengths & Weaknesses
Strengths
-
Chemistry & Fan Service: The bond between Noah and Nick remains the emotional core, and fans of the trilogy will likely feel rewarded by their journey.
-
Visuals & Production Design: The film is glossy, stylish, and polished. Wedding scenes, backgrounds, costume choices—everything looks cinematic and high-budget.
-
Closure Intent: For those who have followed the trilogy, Our Fault attempts to provide closure, resolving lingering arcs and tensions.
Weaknesses
-
Plot Logic & Pacing: Narrative shortcuts and time jumps create confusion. Several viewers noted logic gaps, unclear motivations, and abrupt transitions.
-
Overstuffed Drama: The final act crams in betrayals, secrets, near-death events, and reconciliations. It sometimes feels like too many plot devices in too little time.
-
Dialogue & Emotional Realism: At times, the film drifts into soap opera territory—lines feel overly dramatic or forced rather than grounded. Some critics called the dialogue “clichéd” and “clunky.”
-
Underutilized Side Plots: Secondary characters and arcs often serve as padding rather than meaningful contributors.
One balanced take: The Guardian describes it as “ultra-glossy Spanish step-sibling melodrama… polished visually, but ultimately too bland to offend.”
Despite flaws, the emotional beats work better if you’re already invested in the characters and their saga.
Audience Response & Critic Feedback
Fans of the trilogy often approach Our Fault with high emotional investment—and many express mixed gratitude. Some appreciate the closure and emotional moments even if the logic wobbles. Others feel the film stretches too thin to wrap up the story convincingly.
On social media and Reddit, speculation abounds about the film’s release schedule and whether it can satisfy expectations. Some comments reflect frustration with the pacing and the late inclusion of major plot mechanics.
Critics have generally leaned toward lukewarm reception: while praising production values and performances, many cite narrative weaknesses and over-reliance on melodramatic tropes.
If you’re a casual viewer, the film may feel uneven. But if you’ve followed My Fault and Your Fault, many scenes resonate more deeply.
Where to Watch Our Fault (2025) Online
Good news: Our Fault (Culpa Nuestra) will premiere exclusively on Amazon Prime Video in October 2025.
It is not expected (at least initially) to be offered on rent or purchase platforms separately — it will stream as part of the Prime Video catalog.
Availability in the U.S.
Because Amazon Prime Video operates globally, U.S. users with a Prime subscription will likely access Our Fault alongside other markets. According to coverage:
-
The film will launch in more than 240 countries and territories via Prime Video.
-
Earlier films in the trilogy (My Fault / Your Fault) are already available on Prime Video.
Keep an eye on the listing “Prime Video Originals / International Originals” section in the app as the release date approaches.
To track current availability, you can check platforms like JustWatch once the film drops (or if geolocation-based regions differ). Use the link below as a reference: JustWatch – Our Fault (Culpa Nuestra)
(Note: that link currently refers to the “London” adaptation variant; keep an eye for the Spanish original version’s entry once it becomes available.)
Final Verdict: A Messy Yet Earnest Goodbye
Our Fault doesn’t transcend its melodramatic roots—but then, it doesn’t need to. It succeeds as a fan-oriented emotionally charged finale. If you’re invested in Noah and Nick’s journey, many scenes land with genuine emotional weight. The film’s visual styling, performances, and sense of closure are its greatest assets.
That said, the logic gaps, rushed pacing, and overreliance on drama limit its broader appeal. It’s a satisfying ending mostly for those who have followed the saga, less so for newcomers seeking coherent storytelling.
If you’ve followed My Fault and Your Fault, you’ll want to watch Our Fault to see how this emotional saga ends. Be ready for tears, conflict, and reconciliation—but don’t expect a perfectly logical plot twist every time.
On release day, log into your Amazon Prime Video account and look for it in the International Originals catalog. Meanwhile, consider revisiting the first two films so their themes and characters stay fresh.
And do me a favor: once you’ve watched Our Fault, leave your own review or thoughts in the comments. Did the ending satisfy you? Where did the film succeed or fail for you emotionally or narratively? Sharing helps build a richer conversation and gives feedback to future romantic drama adaptations.
Enjoy the final chapter — and may the faults of the past not define your love story.
