After the Hunt (2025) Movie Review – Where to Watch Online
Italian filmmaker Luca Guadagnino, known for Call Me by Your Name, Bones and All, and Challengers, returns to the big screen in 2025 with his most divisive project yet — After the Hunt. The film stars Julia Roberts, Andrew Garfield, Ayo Edebiri, and Michael Stuhlbarg, and explores the tangled web of morality, truth, and power within elite American academia.
The Story: Academia, Allegations, and the Ambiguity of Truth
At the heart of After the Hunt is Alma Imhoff (Julia Roberts), a respected philosophy professor nearing tenure at a prestigious Ivy League university. Her stable academic world begins to crumble when Maggie Price (Ayo Edebiri), one of her brightest PhD students, accuses Alma’s close colleague — and rumored former lover — Hank Gibson (Andrew Garfield) of sexual assault.
Alma finds herself torn between loyalty, ethics, and survival. When Maggie shows up at Alma’s door in tears, the line between truth and manipulation begins to blur. Hank denies everything, claiming Maggie plagiarized her work. Alma’s psychiatrist husband (Michael Stuhlbarg) offers little comfort as she wrestles with her conscience and career.
The film doesn’t dwell on the legalities of the accusation as much as the psychological consequences that ripple through everyone involved. What happens when truth becomes subjective — when every character has their own version of “what really happened”?
Themes: Generational Conflict and the “Consequence Culture”
One of the strongest aspects of After the Hunt is how it examines the generational divide in dealing with trauma, justice, and public accountability. The film’s setting — a late-2010s pre-pandemic academic world — mirrors our own transition from the old guard of silence to the new age of social accountability.
Where older generations like Alma’s were taught to bury pain to survive, Maggie’s generation demands visibility and action. Guadagnino and screenwriter Nora Garrett weave this tension into every line of dialogue, forcing viewers to ask uncomfortable questions about moral responsibility and whether “cancel culture” is a form of progress or punishment.
The movie doesn’t take sides — and that’s precisely what makes it so compelling. After the Hunt challenges us to sit with ambiguity, to recognize that even the pursuit of justice can be tainted by ego, fear, and ambition.
Performances: Julia Roberts Shines, Garfield Disturbs, Edebiri Impresses
Julia Roberts delivers one of her most layered performances in years. As Alma, she embodies quiet authority laced with guilt, vanity, and self-deception. Roberts’ subtle shifts — a flicker in her eyes, a trembling voice during faculty meetings — reveal a woman unraveling beneath the weight of academic politics and personal demons.
Andrew Garfield sheds his usual charm to portray Hank as a dangerously charismatic man whose motives are impossible to trust. His performance keeps you on edge, constantly questioning whether he’s guilty, misunderstood, or both.
Ayo Edebiri, though given limited screen time, leaves a deep impression as Maggie. Her vulnerability and defiance carry emotional power, especially in scenes where she confronts Alma’s indifference.
And Michael Stuhlbarg as Alma’s detached husband adds a haunting layer to the story — his cool, almost therapeutic demeanor amplifies Alma’s growing isolation.
Direction and Style: Guadagnino’s Visual Precision
Guadagnino’s direction is as meticulous as ever. Every frame feels intentional, every color symbolic. The cinematography leans on warm golds and deep shadows, evoking both prestige and decay — a reflection of the moral rot beneath academic perfection.
The camera often lingers on characters’ faces during tense conversations, pulling viewers into their discomfort. Close-ups blur into shallow focus, mirroring how each person’s truth becomes distorted by emotion and perspective.
The score by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross is another highlight — ticking clocks, anxious tones, and dissonant strings heighten the film’s psychological tension, suggesting that something explosive always lurks beneath the surface.
Writing and Structure: Ambitious but Uneven
While After the Hunt offers plenty to chew on, its narrative structure sometimes stumbles. The film juggles too many subplots — Alma’s past trauma, the university’s politics, Maggie’s emotional unraveling — without giving each the depth they deserve.
Some viewers might find the story convoluted, with threads that never fully resolve. Yet, this messiness also feels intentional — Guadagnino seems less interested in tidy resolutions and more in exposing how people justify their actions when cornered.
The screenplay’s biggest strength lies in its moral ambiguity. Nobody is innocent. Every character is both victim and perpetrator in their own way.
Visual and Thematic Parallels: Between “Tár” and “Doubt”
Many critics have compared After the Hunt to Todd Field’s Tár — another story about power, gender, and accountability in elite spaces. But Guadagnino’s film feels closer in spirit to John Patrick Shanley’s Doubt (2008), where uncertainty itself becomes the main character.
Like Doubt, After the Hunt thrives in tension — not between truth and lies, but between our need for clarity and the uncomfortable reality that some truths are impossible to verify.
Final Thoughts: A Beautifully Flawed Masterpiece
After the Hunt is not an easy film to love — but it’s one that lingers long after the credits roll. It’s contradictory, uncomfortable, and even frustrating at times, but that’s exactly what makes it work.
Guadagnino has crafted a psychological drama for the post-truth era, a mirror held up to our collective confusion about justice, morality, and self-image.
While it may not reach the brilliance of Call Me By Your Name or the energy of Challengers, After the Hunt earns its place as one of 2025’s most thought-provoking and visually stunning films.
Where to Watch After the Hunt (2025) Online
As of October 2025, After the Hunt has not yet been released for streaming or digital rental. However, based on Guadagnino’s distribution history, it’s likely to become available on major platforms such as:
-
Amazon Prime Video (likely purchase/rental option soon)
-
Apple TV / iTunes
-
Google Play Movies & TV
-
Vudu
-
HBO Max (Warner Bros. Discovery partnership speculation)
Keep track of the latest availability here: After the Hunt streaming guide on JustWatch
Official site for updates and purchases: After the Hunt on Amazon
Should You Watch It?
If you’re drawn to intelligent, dialogue-driven dramas that challenge moral certainty, After the Hunt deserves a spot on your watchlist. It’s not for everyone — slow-paced, cerebral, and emotionally thorny — but for those who love psychological depth and stunning cinematography, this film will stay with you long after the lights fade.
Bookmark this page and check JustWatch regularly to see when After the Hunt becomes available to stream or rent online. Guadagnino’s latest might just be the year’s most debated film — and you’ll want to see why.
